Should You Consider Counter Offers?

When you’ve secured a job offer, you may believe your search is over. But you’re not done yet. After you receive an offer, your employer may make a counteroffer. HR and recruitment experts say that accepting a counteroffer is career suicide, period. But in the last several quarters, many recruiters have seen an above-average number…

When you’ve secured a job offer, you may believe your search is over. But you’re not done yet. After you receive an offer, your employer may make a counteroffer. HR and recruitment experts say that accepting a counteroffer is career suicide, period. But in the last several quarters, many recruiters have seen an above-average number of counteroffers.

Why is there an increase? Is it still a bad idea to accept a counteroffer? Let’s look at the factors contributing to this trend, and how both candidates and employers can address it.

Many seek new positions because of frustrations at their current job. And yet, some pursue something new without ever bringing up those frustrations to their supervisor. Some employees don’t have ongoing discussions with their managers to learn where things truly stand. If an employee doesn’t communicate their concerns and frustrations, how could they know if the issues might be resolved?

A frustrated employee may be surprised to learn those issues may be easily solved or mitigated. Bringing up concerns before you seek a new job or accept a new role is a critical step. However, sometimes situations won’t change or leadership is lacking. In today’s struggling job market, some leaders have gotten lazy, and have forgone employee appreciation for the misguided belief that a paycheck should be enough. In that case, it’s time to look for a new job.

Let’s say that as a job seeker, you’ve been offered another position. How might you respond if your current company makes a counteroffer with more money and flexibility, and more interesting projects? You’d be wise to think twice about your answer.

In some cases, counteroffers can be a wonderful opportunity. Unfortunately, they usually aren’t. Ask yourself, why didn’t your employer offer these incentives before? Why did it take the threat of quitting for leadership to take notice and make a change?

Often, a nervous employer realizes just how much money it would cost to replace you. One must remember, though, that an employer will never forget your desire to leave and the lengths it went to keep you. Trust is hard to gain and easy to lose in such situations. Even if the situation at your current employer changes, statistics say those changes likely will be temporary.

For companies that have lost a potential candidate because of a counteroffer from their current employer, think about where you may have improved your interviewing and recruitment process for this candidate. In all likelihood, you failed to identify what the candidate truly wanted and needed.

Was your process detailed and comprehensive? If it was just one-step interview, don’t be surprised if you run into many accepted counteroffers. If you low-balled the candidate on money or time off, or didn’t spend enough time explaining how this opportunity would serve both the organization and the candidate, you missed a key selling point.

You must uncover motivations early and address them throughout the interview process. If you work with a valued recruiter, they may be able to give you more insight into market conditions, pay ranges, benefits and the overall fairness of the offer. Don’t be fooled by the glut of applications you receive; finding topnotch talent is still a challenge in this market.

By refining your process, keeping an eye on what’s in it for the employee and ensuring your offer is desirable, you’ll encounter fewer issues with surprise counteroffers.

Finally, in some cases, the candidate may have gone through a detailed interview process and their motivations were clearly identified and addressed — but they’re still unsure, waffling between your offer and their current employer’s counteroffer. In this case, it’s time to listen to the candidate.

Why are they stalling? Are they scared of change? Can you make any attractive changes to your offer? This isn’t counteroffering, but rather negotiation. Once you’ve done all you can in negotiations, two days is a reasonable time to wait for a response; one week is not. At that point, don’t be afraid to walk away. Fear of losing a good candidate isn’t a good place to negotiate from, and if your hiring process is strong and detailed, you’ll be able to find another good candidate in time.

Applicants: Be diligent, honest and communicate your needs and motivations clearly if you’re seeking new employment.

Employers, remember that a comprehensive interview process will go far in preventing unwanted surprises for both the candidate and you.

The Latest Updates

03.18.2024

Employee retention matters. Organisational issues such as training time and investment, lost knowledge, mourning, insecure co-workers and a costly candidate search aside; failing to retain a key employee is costly. Various estimates suggest that losing a middle manager costs an organisation up to 100 percent of their salary. The loss of a senior executive is…

AI, An Essential Future Tool in Recruitment and Selection
03.18.2024

It is widely acknowledged that finding and hiring superior talent is a major source of competitive advantage for organisations, hence keeping abreast of the tools involved in the hiring process is, by itself, a source of competitive advantage. If we reflect on changes to hiring over the last 30 years, a revolution has taken place….

02.20.2024

Welcome aboard! The first few days and weeks in a new role can set the tone for an individual’s entire journey within an organisation. Hence, it is paramount to make these initial stages count. Let’s explore why timing matters and how to optimise it for the best onboarding experience. Why Timing Matters First Impressions Are…

What’s new?

Top Ten Tips to Retain Your Employees: Understanding the Importance

Employee retention matters. Organisational issues such as training time and investment, lost knowledge, mourning, insecure co-workers and a costly candidate search aside; failing to retain a key employee is costly. Various estimates suggest that losing a middle manager costs an organisation up to 100 percent of their salary. The loss of a senior executive is…

AI, An Essential Future Tool in Recruitment and Selection
AI, An Essential Future Tool in Recruitment and Selection.

It is widely acknowledged that finding and hiring superior talent is a major source of competitive advantage for organisations, hence keeping abreast of the tools involved in the hiring process is, by itself, a source of competitive advantage. If we reflect on changes to hiring over the last 30 years, a revolution has taken place….

Mastering the Art of Onboarding: Creating an Impactful Introduction for New Team Members.

Welcome aboard! The first few days and weeks in a new role can set the tone for an individual’s entire journey within an organisation. Hence, it is paramount to make these initial stages count. Let’s explore why timing matters and how to optimise it for the best onboarding experience. Why Timing Matters First Impressions Are…

Skills Based Hiring. A Step Towards Solving Talent Shortages in 2024?

In addressing talent shortages across various industries, employers’ traditional approach of hiring based on qualifications and years of experience is proving inadequate. A shift towards skills-based hiring is gaining momentum, offering a promising solution. This practice involves a reassessment of the job requirements and determining instead the underlying skills that are required. It may also…

Year in Review

Another year is quickly coming to a close… the first half of 2023 saw a firm demand for skilled people in the agriculture and food sectors. Despite the scarcity of talent, we successfully filled  a record number of jobs in the first half of the year.  The mid-year forecast of a return of El Nino and…

How Filling Empty Seats in Your Business Can Lead to Success

In today’s competitive market, it’s more important than ever to have a talented and engaged workforce. But when key roles are left unfilled, it can have a negative impact on your bottom line. Here are just a few of the ways that empty seats can impact your business: Inhibited growth: When you don’t have the…

Talent Market in Ag
Job Ads down, Applications up: Talent Market in Australia’s Ag industry remains competitive

The latest SEEK employment trends data for the Australian agriculture sector, shows that job ads have decreased by 9.6% across all categories except Conservation, Parks and Wildlife, compared to last year. However, applications are up, compared to the five-year average. 78% of candidates are currently actively looking or monitoring the market, the highest level in…

Competitive Positioning in a Candidate-Poor Talent Market

In an industry such as agribusiness, it is essential that commercial companies adapt their hiring processes to source top talent to drive their business growth. One way of achieving this is to tap into a broader talent pool and in a candidate-poor talent market, this is the key to competitive positioning. We recently conducted a national…

The State of Women’s Careers in the Agricultural Workforce

As we celebrated International Day of Rural Women on the weekend, let’s revisit an article published by Margaret Alston, Professor of Social Work, University of Newcastle about women in the agricultural workforce of Australia from our 2020 Trend Report. The contribution of women in agriculture has been historically ignored in Australia, even when at least…

Why Commercial Companies Avoid Using Recruitment Agencies for Employee Hiring – Cost Considerations

Recruitment agencies play a significant role in connecting job seekers with employers, providing a range of services, including candidate sourcing, screening, and selection. However, in our recent survey of Australian agribusinesses we were surprised to see that only about 20% of agribusinesses used a recruitment company to find potential candidates. This analysis aims to explore…